Weight loss on low-fat vs. low-carbohydrate diets by insulin resistance status among overweight and obese adults: a randomized pilot trial (Gardner et al., 2015)
Low carb diet: participants went from 230 grams/d to less than 50 for the first 3 months, then creeped up to ~80 over the next 3 months.
Will the critics say “the carbz weren’t low enough!”? REALLY?
Background reading:
Carbs: Low vs. Lower
Insulin Resistance (includes a great video by Gardner)
Personalized Nutrition by Prediction of Glycemic Response
In brief, the one-size-fits-all diet theory is #fail.
Don’t be tied down to one approach; different #contexts require different approaches, and both can change over time.
—
On to the new study:
At baseline, patients were divided into insulin sensitive & resistant groups based on insulin levels (AUC) during an oral glucose tolerance test. Then those groups were assigned to either a low fat or low carb diet. There were four groups, three time points (baseline, 3 months, and 6 months).
To make a long story short, insulin sensitive patients randomized to the low fat diet lost about 20% more weight than those randomized to low carb. Read that sentence again (just the part in bold).
Insulin sensitive dieters lost more weight on a high carb diet than a low carb diet (10.4 vs 8.6 kg). Insulin resistant dieters lost more weight on low carb (9.6 vs 7.4 kg). Notably, of all four groups, the most weight was lost on a high carb diet (10.4 kg) despite low carbers consistently getting more protein.
Don’t be a science denier!
Body comp assessment would’ve been nice, but whatevs…
Was there a lot of overlap? yes (EVERYONE lost weight)
Was there statistical significance? no, except metabolic parameters improved more so in people assigned to the insulin-appropriate diet (ie, LC for IR, LF for IS).
Are these data meaningful? YES
I say this because the differences are very close to the magnitude we’d expect in these populations. Insulin sensitive dieters lost 20% more weight if they were assigned to a low fat diet, but they still lost weight on low carb… we wouldn’t expect insulin sensitive dieters to gain weight on a low carb diet, just lose a little less because it’s not optimal in this #context.
Are there a million other factors involved here? YES. Insulin sensitivity is only one of ’em, but a pretty good starting point.
Theoretical scenario: a sedentary, obese insulin resistant patient starts off on LC and is initially successful. They start exercising and focusing on sleep quality, insulin sensitivity improves (ie, new #context)... but weight loss stalls in many of these people. Maybe at this point they would benefit more by switching the focus from strict LC to monitoring other things, like calorie or fat intake (ie, to match the new #context) –> progress resumes.
Maybe.
Don’t be tied down to one approach; different #contexts require different approaches, and both can change over time.
That’s all, for now.
Chris Gardner strikes again!https://t.co/XrQV61OJJ5
— Bill Lagakos (@CaloriesProper) March 26, 2016
If you like what I do and want to support it, head over to Patreon! Three bucks a month gets you full access, but sign up soon because there are only a few spaces left at the $3 level — then it jumps to $5 *gasp*
It’s ad-free and you can cancel if it sucks ????
Affiliate discounts: if you’re still looking for a pair of hot blue blockers, Carbonshade is offering 15% off with the coupon code LAGAKOS and Spectra479 is offering 15% off HERE. TrueDark is running a pretty big sale HERE. If you have no idea what I’m talking about, read this then this.
20% off some delish stocks and broths from Kettle and Fire HERE.
If you want the benefits of ‘shrooms but don’t like eating them, Real Mushrooms makes great extracts. 10% off with coupon code LAGAKOS. (I recommend Lion’s Mane for the brain and Reishi for everything else).